Estate of Marvin M. Schwan - Page 10




                                       - 10 -                                         
                    Questions and controversies have arisen between                   
               counsel for the Foundation and counsel for the Company                 
               regarding the interpretation of * * * the Redemption                   
               Agreement.  One interpretation would require the                       
               Company to purchase, and the Foundation to sell, all of                
               the Shares.  Another interpretation would require the                  
               Company to purchase, and the Foundation to sell, only                  
               the voting shares.  The Foundation and the Company                     
               understand that it is uncertain how a court would                      
               resolve the varying interpretations of the Redemption                  
               Agreement.                                                             
          The instrument then provided that the Foundation would sell, and            
          SSE would purchase, all of the shares, both voting and nonvoting,           
          at an initial purchase price of $869,450,800.                               
               Also on August 4, 1994, decedent’s Federal estate tax return           
          was signed by Lawrence, Mark, and Paul.  The return was received            
          by respondent on August 10, 1994.  Therein, decedent’s SSE stock            
          was valued at $869,450,800 in his gross estate, and a charitable            
          deduction was taken in that same amount for the bequest of the              
          shares to the Foundation.  Similarly, the above-referenced                  
          redemption transaction was completed on August 23, 1994, with the           
          Foundation receiving cash and a note totaling $869,450,800.                 
               After the foregoing events, in May of 1995, Lorrie, Mark,              
          David, and Paul, individually and as parents of decedent’s                  
          grandchildren, filed suit in the U.S. District Court for the                
          District of Minnesota against SSE, the Foundation, Alfred, and              
          Lawrence.  In their amended complaint, the plaintiffs brought               
          numerous direct and derivative claims based principally on the              
          contention that, under the Redemption Agreement, “Schwan’s was to           






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011