D. G. Smalley and Nell R. Smalley - Page 8




                                        - 8 -                                         
               The purchase of these three replacement properties exhausted           
          all but $205.45 of the escrow funds.  By check dated May 9, 1995,           
          Lewis paid petitioner the $205.45 balance.                                  
               Petitioners are cash basis taxpayers.  On their joint 1994             
          Federal income tax return, filed on or about April 15, 1995, they           
          characterized the subject transaction as a like-kind exchange of            
          “Timber” for “Timber and Land”, giving rise to $496,076 realized            
          gain, all of which they treated as deferred gain pursuant to                
          section 1031.                                                               
               In the notice of deficiency, dated December 4, 1997,                   
          respondent determined that petitioners realized gain of $489,935,           
          instead of $496,076, from their 1994 timber sale.2  The notice of           
          deficiency states that “the realized gain from the sale of the              
          timber is to be fully recognized [in 1994] because it has not               
          been established that the requirements of section 1031 of the               
          Internal Revenue Code have been met.”                                       
                                       OPINION                                        
          A.  The Parties’ Contentions                                                
               1.  The Like-Kind Exchange Requirement                                 
               Petitioners argue that to continue petitioner’s timber                 
          investment, he exchanged standing timber for standing timber that           



               2 The parties have stipulated that petitioner’s basis in the           
          timber conveyed to Rayonier was $3,200.  On brief, respondent               
          contends that after subtracting this basis, the amount of                   
          petitioners’ realized gain is $486,735.                                     





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011