Michael T. Caracci and Cindy W. Caracci, et al. - Page 26




                                       - 26 -                                         
          on the valuation of home health care agencies and has frequently            
          appeared as an expert witness.                                              
               Hahn started by noting that because of the predominance of             
          Medicare in the payor mix of most home health agencies, a                   
          conventional cashflow or earnings approach to valuation would               
          produce “a very different result from other, more appropriate               
          approaches.”  This is so because home health agencies, with a               
          preponderance of Medicare-eligible patients, earn little if any             
          profit.7                                                                    
               Hahn instead relied principally upon an “Adjusted Balance              
          Sheet” methodology, a form of the cost approach.  That                      
          methodology restates a company’s accounting balance sheet to its            
          fair market value equivalent.  Hahn explained that this approach            
          involves the identification and valuation of tangible and                   
          intangible assets and liabilities, whether or not they appear on            
          the subject company’s accounting balance sheet.                             
               Hahn started with the unaudited balance sheets prepared by             
          petitioners’ accounting firm in 1995.  He concluded that several            
          of the Sta-Home tax-exempt entities’ asset accounts required                
          revaluation.  He noted that there were several “unrecorded                  


               7 The evidence includes an article written by Hahn wherein             
          he reports that his firm’s database reflects that “more than 75             
          percent of home health agency acquisitions involved agencies that           
          recorded losses.”  Hahn, “Payment Reform Will Shift Home Health             
          Agency Valuation Parameters”, Healthcare Financial Management               
          (Dec. 1998).                                                                






Page:  Previous  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011