Estate of Charles N. Aronson, Deceased, Barney P. Aronson, Executor - Page 49

                                       - 49 -                                         
               Except in the case of a trust which is revocable by                    
               such person during lifetime, a power conferred upon a                  
               person in his or her capacity as trustee of an express                 
               trust to make discretionary distribution of either                     
               principal or income to himself or herself or to make                   
               discretionary allocations in his or her own favor of                   
               receipts or expenses as between principal and income,                  
               cannot be exercised by him or her. * * *  If there is                  
               no trustee qualified to execute the power, its                         
               execution devolves on the supreme court or the                         
               surrogate’s court, except that if the power is created                 
               by will, its execution devolves on the surrogate’s                     
               court having jurisdiction of the estate of the donor of                
               the power.                                                             
          The trust in the 1993 will did not give Bar discretionary power             
          to make distributions of income or principal to himself or                  
          allocations in his own favor.  Even if it did, this power would             
          devolve on the Surrogate’s Court.  Furthermore, N.Y. EPTL section           
          10-10.1 does not give Bar or the Surrogate’s Court the power to             
          pay Jo any more than she needs.9                                            
               We conclude that the interest in the trust created by the              
          1993 will does not qualify for the estate tax marital deduction             
          as “qualified terminable interest property” within the meaning of           
          section 2056(b)(7).  In reaching our holding herein, we have                
          considered all arguments made by the parties, and to the extent             
          not mentioned above, we find them to be irrelevant or without               
          merit.                                                                      



               9  Even if N.Y. Est. Powers & Trusts Law sec. 10-10.1                  
          (McKinney 2003) required Bar to pay all the income of the trust             
          to Jo, it does not require him to pay it to her annually or at              
          more frequent intervals.                                                    




Page:  Previous  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  49  50  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011