Tibor Guenther Horwath and Christel Horwath - Page 16

                                       - 16 -                                         
          issue to the respective depreciation deductions that they are               
          claiming with respect to that simulator.6                                   
               For the sake of completeness, we shall address whether,                
          assuming arguendo (1) that SDC transferred the computer simulator           
          to TGC by gift and (2) that any such gift is treated as a gift to           
          petitioners for purposes of determining petitioners’ entitlement            
          for the taxable years at issue to depreciation deductions with              
          respect to that simulator, petitioners have established the                 
          amounts of such depreciation deductions to which they are enti-             
          tled.  Petitioners argue that their basis in the computer simula-           
          tor under section 1015(a) is SDC’s basis in that simulator, i.e.,           
          SDC’s cost of that simulator.  According to petitioners, SDC’s              
          cost of, and thus its basis in, the computer simulator was                  
          $1,049,117, the amount that SDC paid to TGC pursuant to the 1992            
          contract, and not the $215,000 that petitioners claimed in Form             
          4562 relating to Mr. Horwath’s 1997 Schedule C.7                            
               On the record before us, we reject petitioners’ argument.              
          Section 167(c) provides in pertinent part:  “The basis on which             


               6The record establishes that at the time the 1992 contract             
          was terminated around Nov. 6, 1997, the computer simulator was              
          the property of TGC.  Assuming arguendo that SDC transferred the            
          computer simulator to TGC by gift, the record does not establish            
          that TGC owned the computer simulator prior to the termination of           
          the 1992 contract.                                                          
               7The $215,000 that petitioners claimed as their basis in the           
          computer simulator in Form 4562 represented petitioners’ best               
          estimate of the replacement cost of that simulator.                         





Page:  Previous  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011