Milton M. Scarborough, Petitioner and Judy H. Scarborough Barrentine, Intervenor - Page 9

                                        - 8 -                                         
          all eight factors in his case memorandum, we shall consider all             
          eight factors.  We reach the following conclusions:                         
               – Marital status.  At the time petitioner made the request,            
          he was divorced from intervenor, which is considered a positive             
          factor.                                                                     
               – Economic hardship.  Petitioner failed to show economic               
          hardship, which failure is considered a negative factor.                    
               – Abuse.  Petitioner failed to show abuse, which failure is            
          considered a neutral factor.                                                
               – No knowledge or reason to know.  Petitioner failed to show           
          that, at the time he signed the 1999 return, he had no knowledge            
          or reason to know that intervenor would not pay the 1999 tax                
          liability.  Petitioner signed the 1999 return after he and                  
          intervenor had separated and after intervenor had filed for                 
          divorce.  Putting aside any ambiguity in the settlement                     
          agreement, that agreement was not entered into until almost 11              
          months after the return was filed.  Petitioner’s reliance on the            
          settlement agreement to show that he believed intervenor would              
          pay one-half of the 1999 liability is therefore misplaced.  This            
          factor is negative.                                                         
               – Legal obligation of nonrequesting spouse.  The settlement            
          agreement is ambiguous, and respondent did not abuse his                    
          discretion in considering this factor to be neutral.                        








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011