Herbert V. Kohler, Jr., et al. - Page 37

                                        -37-                                          
          alternate valuation date was $47.010 million.  Mr. Schweihs used            
          a similar analysis to value the pre-reorganization shares on the            
          date of Frederic’s death, 6 months earlier, and determined the              
          fair market value of those shares on the date of Frederic’s death           
          was $50.115 million.                                                        
                    2.   Mr. Grabowski’s Valuation                                    
               Mr. Grabowski was another expert who prepared an appraisal             
          report and testified for the estate.  He has been valuing                   
          companies since 1974, first with S&P Corporate Value Consulting             
          and since September 2005, as a managing director with Duff &                
          Phelps.  He is a member of the ASA and is an accredited senior              
          appraiser with the ASA in business valuation.  He has taught                
          finance and valuation courses at Loyola University, taught                  
          classes for the ASA, and teaches a class on cost of capital.  The           
          majority of his work is valuation services in nonlitigation                 
          settings, and he has valued several businesses similar to Kohler,           
          including plumbing fixture businesses and closely held companies.           
               Mr. Grabowski spent 3-1/2 days at the company and                      
          interviewed 12 employees, spending considerable time with 6 of              
          them, including Herbert (the President and Chairman of the Board)           
          and Natalie (the General Counsel).  Mr. Grabowski also reviewed             
          numerous documents and considered general economic conditions and           
          the industries in which Kohler operates.                                    







Page:  Previous  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011