Estate of Lillie Rosen, Deceased, Ilene Field and Herbert Silver, Co-Personal Representatives - Page 61

                                         -61-                                         
          solely) on the earnings and assets of the LRFLP.  The only way              
          that decedent could have repaid those amounts would have been for           
          the LRFLP to distribute formally some of its earnings to her or             
          to redeem her limited partnership interest at a price greater               
          than the amount reported as due.  While petitioners assert that             
          the “loans” were ultimately repaid in connection with the                   
          redemption of the Lillie Investment Trust’s limited partnership             
          interest, such a post mortem transaction serves only to                     
          strengthen our finding that decedent continued to enjoy the                 
          transferred assets up until her death.                                      
               This factor weighs toward a finding that decedent’s use of             
          the funds of the LRFLP did not create bona fide debt.                       
                    v.  Capitalization                                                
               Thin or inadequate capitalization to fund a transferee’s               
          obligations weighs against a finding of bona fide debt.  See                
          Stinnett’s Pontiac Serv., Inc. v. Commissioner, supra at 639.               
               We consider this factor to be irrelevant in the context of             
          this case and give it no weight.                                            
                    vi.  Identity of Interest                                         
               Transfers made in proportion to ownership interests weigh              
          against a finding of bona fide debt.  A sharply disproportionate            
          ratio between an ownership interest and the debt owing to the               
          transferor by the transferee generally weighs toward a finding of           







Page:  Previous  47  48  49  50  51  52  53  54  55  56  57  58  59  60  61  62  63  64  65  66  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011