Robert and Ines M. Gillespie, et al. - Page 37




                                       - 37 -                                         
          Commissioner’s trial and supervisory attorneys in 2002, in Takaba           
          v. Commissioner, 119 T.C. at 304-305.                                       
               Mr. Jones does not question the reasonableness of the hourly           
          rates claimed for Messrs. Tomsic, Wong, and Feinberg.  Mr. Jones            
          has principally two objections to the award of excess costs.                
          First, he objects to respondent’s claim that all of the hours               
          expended by his attorneys are excessive and deserving of                    
          compensation.  Second, he claims that respondent fails to                   
          describe and substantiate the nature of the services rendered by            
          his attorneys.                                                              
               We see no merit to either of Mr. Jones’s objections.  As we            
          have made plain, these cases are without merit and never should             
          have been brought.  By their declarations, Messrs. Tomsic, Wong,            
          and Feinberg describe adequately their activities with respect to           
          these cases.  Messrs. Tomsic’s and Wong’s declarations are                  
          accompanied by computer records that, we assume, were made                  
          contemporaneously with the work performed and support their                 
          claims.  Moreover, we are familiar with the procedural and                  
          factual history of these cases, and we believe that 12 hours was            
          reasonably necessary for Mr. Tomsic to do the work he describes.            
          We find that $150 is a reasonable hourly charge for Mr. Tomsic’s            
          time, and he reasonably expended 12 hours on this litigation.               
          The lodestar amount for Mr. Tomsic is, thus, $1,800.  We believe            
          that 72 hours was reasonably necessary for Mr. Wong to do the               







Page:  Previous  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  Next 

Last modified: November 10, 2007