Linda K. Minton - Page 6




                                        - 6 -                                         
          and, like Julian W. and petitioner, one $5,000 distribution.                
          Also, in 1993, LPP made four $522 payments to a bank on behalf of           
          Julian E.  In 1996, there were distributions to Julian E. in the            
          form of tax payments on his behalf.4                                        
               For 1993-95, LPP’s total distributions to shareholders                 
          closely approximated the 42-29-29-percent ownership interests of            
          Julian E., Julian W., and petitioner, respectively, as reflected            
          on LPP’s 1993-95 returns as filed.5                                         
          Petitioner’s 1998 and Amended 1996 and 1997 Returns and LPP’s               
          1997 and 1998 Returns                                                       
               During the course of litigation in the Louisiana State                 
          courts instituted by petitioner against LPP, Julian E., Julian              
          W., and others with respect to the number of LPP shares owned by            




               4  The record contains no evidence as to the actual amounts            
          of the monthly payments to Julian E. from 1986 to 1992, and only            
          petitioner’s testimony that they, in fact, were made.                       
               5  We make no findings of fact regarding ownership of the              
          100 shares between 1990, after Alma died, and 1996 when Julian W.           
          and petitioner each became the owner of 50 of the 100 shares.  In           
          2001, LPP’s accountant represented to respondent that LPP’s                 
          1986-95 returns show that Julian E. held 42 percent of its shares           
          and Julian W. and petitioner, 29 percent each, and that,                    
          effective January 1996, Julian E. conveyed all of his LPP shares            
          to Julian W. and petitioner, one-half to each.  That                        
          representation is corroborated by trial testimony given in an               
          earlier Louisiana State court proceeding by LPP’s prior                     
          accountant.  There is, however, contradictory evidence in the               
          record indicating that (1) at the time of her death in 1990, Alma           
          owned a one-half community interest with Julian E. in 42 shares             
          of LPP stock, (2) she bequeathed the shares represented by that             
          interest (21 shares) to Julian W. and petitioner, 10.5 shares to            
          each, thereby giving each 39.5 shares or a 39.5-percent interest            
          in LPP as of 1990, and (3) in 1996, Julian E. transferred 21                
          shares to his children, not 42 shares.                                      





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: March 27, 2008