PSB Holdings, Inc. - Page 13




                                       - 13 -                                         
          sections 265(b)(2) and 291(e)(1)(B) as if it were acquired on               
          August 7, 1986; thus, qualified tax-exempt obligations reduce               
          interest expense deductions under section 291(a)(3) and                     
          (e)(1)(B), rather than under section 265(b).  The parties agree             
          that the tax-exempt obligations owned by Investments are                    
          “qualified tax-exempt obligations”.                                         
               In calculating the amount of the denominator for Peoples,              
          the parties agree that the denominator includes Peoples’ adjusted           
          basis in its Investments stock.  The parties lock horns on                  
          whether the tax-exempt obligations purchased and owned by                   
          Investments must be included in the numerator.  On the                      
          consolidated returns, Peoples omitted those obligations from the            
          numerator.  Respondent determined that those obligations are                
          included in the numerator.  As respondent sees it, because the              
          basis of Peoples’ Investments stock is included in the                      
          denominator, the portion of that basis attributable to the bases            
          of Investments’ tax-exempt obligations is included in the                   
          numerator.                                                                  
               We begin our analysis with the relevant text.  We interpret            
          the text with reference to the legislative history primarily to             
          learn the purpose of the statutes and to resolve any ambiguity in           
          the text.  See United States v. Am. Trucking Associations, Inc.,            
          310 U.S. 534, 543-544 (1940).  We apply the text as written                 
          unless we find that a word’s meaning is “‘inescapably ambiguous’”           







Page:  Previous  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next 

Last modified: March 27, 2008