Rhett Rance Smith and Alice Avila Smith, et al. - Page 41




                                        - 41 -                                        
          corporate general partners’ consent.  Therefore, the interests              
          could not be converted to cash or other property that could be              
          used to fund charitable activities without petitioners’                     
          agreement.  By the end of 1998, the sole asset in each FLP was              
          Beneco stock.  Beneco did not pay any dividends before 1995, and            
          no dividends were paid thereafter and through the years in issue.           
          The decision for Beneco to pay dividends appeared to rest solely            
          with petitioners.  Therefore, the donee-charity would likely be             
          relegated to waiting until the deaths of petitioners before                 
          receiving cash or property that could be used to fund charitable            
          activity.                                                                   
               Zane and Shannon’s 1998 contribution and Rhett and Alice’s             
          2000 contribution consisted solely of economic interests in their           
          respective FLPs.  It is not clear what status or role CCF played            
          in the respective FLPs.  No express distinction was made between            
          limited partners and any charitable donees who held interests in            
          the FLPs.                                                                   
               The contributions were ascribed values in round dollar                 
          amounts (e.g., $145,000) that were converted to percentages                 
          in each FLP on the basis of the Beneco stock values petitioners             
          used to establish the amounts of the deductions.  As described              
          below, the Forms 8283 attached to the returns were prepared in an           
          inattentive and incomplete manner.                                          








Page:  Previous  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  Next 

Last modified: March 27, 2008