Charles A. and Marian L. Derby, et al. - Page 47




                                        - 47 -                                        
          acquirers of their medical practices; and (5) rather than a                 
          noncompete agreement, the "free to compete" provision, which                
          secured for each petitioner the express right, upon his or her              
          termination of employment with SWMG/SMF, to have his or her                 
          patients as of the date of affiliation with SMF notified of the             
          departure and given the option of having the patient's medical              
          records transferred to the departing physician.  In addition, when          
          petitioners' circumstances before the transaction are considered,           
          a second tier of benefits they secured in the transaction with SMF          
          becomes apparent.  First, petitioners solved their core economic            
          problem arising from the advent of managed care; namely, the risk           
          of loss from having patients requiring extraordinary care.  After           
          the transaction, by virtue of the minimum compensation guaranties,          
          this risk was largely transferred to SMF, which could better                
          manage it given SMF's greater patient population and resources.             
          Second, as a result of their affiliation with a relatively large            
          health care organization, petitioners secured the benefits of               
          greater leverage in negotiating contracts with HMO's and greater            
          efficiencies in providing care, with any resulting enhancement in           
          revenues inuring to their benefit by virtue of SWMG's compensation          
          being determined as a percentage of net revenues.  In sum, by               
          transferring their practices to SMF in the transaction at issue,            
          petitioners ensured for themselves the continued ability to                 
          maintain or improve their accustomed level of earnings from the             







Page:  Previous  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  49  50  51  52  53  54  Next 

Last modified: March 27, 2008