Ex Parte Rosengart et al - Page 9


                 Appeal No.  2007-0531                                                          Page 9                   
                 Application No.  10/341,679                                                                             

                                4. VEGF “can also be employed to repair vascular damage                                  
                                   following myocardial infarction and to circumvent the need for                        
                                   coronary bypass surgery by stimulating the growth of a                                
                                   collateral circulation.”  Column 13, lines 24-28.                                     
                                5. VEGF can be directly injected “to the site of damaged cardiac                         
                                   muscle.”  Column 13, lines 31-32.                                                     
                                6. that VEGF can be applied in conjunction with procedures that                          
                                   compress atherosclerotic plaques.  Column 12, lines 48-52.                            
                                Tischer does not:                                                                        
                                       1.  teach replication-deficient adenovirus constructs                             
                                          comprising VEGF121.                                                            
                                       2. teach injection of a replication defective recombinant                         
                                          adenoviral vector comprising VEGF121 DNA directly to the                       
                                          internal surface of the heart.  We do not interpret                            
                                          Tischer’s disclosure of injection to the site of damaged                       
                                          cardiac muscle to mean inject VEGF121 on the inside                            
                                          surface of the heart.                                                          
                        Isner teaches:                                                                                   
                                1. “nucleic acid . . . capable of expressing an angiogenic protein (a                    
                                   protein capable of inducing angiogenesis . . .), when injected                        
                                   into ischemic tissue, induces angiogenesis. . . .”  Column 2,                         
                                   lines 41-46.                                                                          
                                2. “a method for treating ischemic tissue [(including ischemic                           
                                   cardiomyopathy and myocardial ischemia)] in a mammal which                            
                                   comprises injecting said tissue with an effective amount of a                         
                                   nucleic acid capable of expressing an angiogenic protein.”                            
                                   Column 2, lines 50-53.                                                                
                                3. “the term ‘angiogenic protein’ means any protein, polypeptide,                        
                                   mutein or portion that is capable of, directly or indirectly,                         
                                   inducing the formation of new blood vessels.  Such proteins                           
                                   include, for example . . . VEGF . . . ” and more particularly,                        
                                   human VEGF165.  Column 3, lines 9-14 and 62-66.                                       
                                4. “[t]he nucleic acid can be injected at multiple sites throughout                      
                                   the ischemic tissue.”  Column 6, lines 27-28.                                         






Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013