Ex Parte Brown et al - Page 6

                Appeal 2007-2955                                                                              
                Application 10/190,425                                                                        

                16. “[M]odification of wells with specific cell-binding molecules permits                     
                selective binding of cells to specific wells” (Taylor, col. 12, ll. 1-4), and                 
                “allows one well, a group of wells or the entire array to specifically                        
                ‘recognize’, grow and screen cells from a mixed population of cells” (id.                     
                at 12, ll. 9-12).                                                                             
                17. Taylor’s “cell recognition” or “cell-binding” molecules include                           
                antibodies, lectins, and extracellular matrix proteins (Taylor, col. 13, ll.                  
                25-28), and  Taylor’s “base” “can be a glass, plastic, or silicon wafer, such                 
                as a . . . coverslip” (id. at col. 8, ll. 37-39).                                             
                18. “The density of cells attached to the wells is controlled by the cell                     
                density in the cell suspension, the time permitted for cell attachment . . .                  
                and/or the density of cell binding molecules in the wells” (Taylor, col. 12, ll.              
                24-27).                                                                                       
                19. Taylor differs from the claimed invention in that the cell-recognition                    
                molecules (i.e., probes) are bound to hydrophilic spots on an otherwise                       
                hydrophobic base (i.e., solid support), rather than being “deposited as spots                 
                on the surface of a hydrated gel coated solid support,” as required by instant                
                claim 1.                                                                                      
                Wagner                                                                                        
                20. Wagner is directed to “an array of protein-capture agents comprising:                     
                a substrate; at least one organic thinfilm covering some or all of the surface                
                of the substrate; and a plurality of patches arranged in discrete, known                      
                regions on the portions of the substrate surface covered by organic thinfilm,                 
                wherein (i) each patch comprises protein-capture agents immobilized on the                    
                organic thinfilm, where the protein-capture agents of a given patch are                       


                                                      6                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013