Ex parte MATHIOWITZ - Page 9




          Appeal No. 95-2876                                                          
          Application 07/906,403                                                      


          but rather in an intermediate layer."  See Brief, page 14.  We              
          note that Appelgren's intermediate (first) layer containing a               
          polymer and a drug, as indicated by the examiner at page 7 of               
          the Answer, is included by the claimed coating polymer layer                
          containing a substance (drug).                                              
               Appellants argue that Appelgren does not suggest forming               
          a coating polymer layer of uniform thickness.  In so arguing,               
          appellants fail to consider Appelgren in its entirety.                      
          Appelgren, for example, indicates at column 3, lines 52-54,                 
          that the shape of the spherical or nearly spherical particles               
          is dependent on the shape of the cores, not the intermediate                
          (first) or second layers.  This statement implies that the                  
          thicknesses of the intermediate and second layers are uniform               
          or substantially uniform such that they do not affect the                   
          shape of the spherical or nearly spherical particles.  The                  
          implication is further galvanized by Appelgren's requirement                
          for "in vivo a sustained release".  See column 3, line 63.  To              
          maintain a sustained release of a desired amount of a drug, it              
          would appear that the thicknesses of the intermediate and                   
          second layers of Appelgren need to be uniform.  In any event,               
          since the types or thicknesses (amount) of polymers affect the              
                                          9                                           





Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007