Ex parte DOWNS - Page 2




                Appeal No. 95-3273                                                                                                            
                Application 08/136,856                                                                                                        

                Geil et al. Patent 4,833,659 is repeated in the Answer.   In                                2                                 
                addition to maintaining the rejection based on Geil et al., the                                                               
                Answer added new grounds of rejection based on Rokurota Patent                                                                
                4,747,192.                                                                                                                    
                                 The invention is a piezoelectric microphone structure.                                                       
                Claim 1, which is one of three independent claims on appeal                                                                   
                (claims 10 and 11 are the others), reads as follows:                                                                          
                                 1.  A surface-laminated piezoelectric-                                                                       
                                 film sound transducer, comprising:                                                                           
                                 A.  a thin film of piezoelectric material having two                                                         
                                 opposite faces,                                                                                              
                                 B.  two thin films of conductive                                                                             
                                 material, one of said films of                                                                               
                                 conductive material being affixed to one                                                                     
                                 of said two opposite faces and another                                                                       
                                 of said films of conductive material                                                                         
                                 being affixed to another of said two                                                                         
                                 opposite faces, thereby forming a                                                                            
                                 piezoelectric sandwich element with the                                                                      
                                 thin film of piezoelectric material in                                                                       
                                 the middle and the two thin films of                                                                         
                                 conductive material on the outside,                                                                          
                                 C.  a solid, flat, substantially                                                                             
                                 inflexible substrate laminated to the                                                                        
                                 piezoelectric sandwich element along                                                                         
                                 substantially the entire surface of one                                                                      
                                 of the two conductive layers, and                                                                            


                2The grounds of rejection which were not repeated in the                                                                      
                Answer, i.e., the rejections based on D'Hoog Patent 3,941,932,                                                                
                Takeuchi et al. Patent 5,210,455, Dewberry et al. Patent                                                                      
                4,013,992, are treated as withdrawn.                                                                                          

                                                                    -2-                                                                       





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007