Ex parte GRISWOLD - Page 17




          Appeal No. 95-3919                                                          
          Application No. 07/907,934                                                  


          because appellant has grouped this claim with claim 201                     
          (Brief, page 4).                                                            
               For all of the reasons expressed supra in connection with              
          claim 138, the obviousness rejection of claim 205 is                        
          sustained.                                                                  
               The obviousness rejection of claims 206 and 207 is                     
          sustained because appellant has grouped these claims with                   
          claim 201 (Brief, page 4).                                                  
               The obviousness rejection of claims 208 and 209 is                     
          reversed because Katznelson does not compare an “expiration                 
          date” with a date at which a request is received.                           
               The obviousness rejection of claims 210 and 211 is                     
          sustained because appellant has not presented any                           
          patentability arguments for these claims.                                   
               The obviousness rejection of claims 212 and 213 is                     
          reversed because a request in Katznelson does not “include                  
          data indicative of the number of processes,” and because                    
          Katznelson does not deny use of a product “if more than a                   
          predetermined number of processes” using the product are                    
          running at terminal 11.                                                     
               The obviousness rejection of claim 214 is sustained                    
                                         17                                           





Page:  Previous  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007