Ex parte GRISWOLD - Page 12




          Appeal No. 95-3919                                                          
          Application No. 07/907,934                                                  


               The obviousness rejection of claims 157 and 158 is                     
          reversed because terminal 11 in Katznelson does not generate                
          requests “at regular time intervals.”                                       
               The obviousness rejection of claims 159 through 168 is                 
          reversed because terminal 11 in Katznelson does not send a                  
          request to terminal 10 while a product from the CD-ROM “is in               
          use.”                                                                       
               For all of the reasons expressed supra in connection with              
          claim 132, the obviousness rejection of claim 169 is                        
          sustained.                                                                  
               The obviousness rejection of claim 170 is reversed                     
          because terminal 11 in Katznelson does not send a request “at               
          regular time intervals during use” of a product on CD-ROM.                  
               The obviousness rejection of claim 171 is sustained                    
          because a particular data product on the CD-ROM is identified               
          in the request.                                                             
               For all of the reasons expressed supra in connection with              
          claim 135, the obviousness rejection of claim 172 is                        
          sustained.                                                                  
               For all of the reasons expressed supra in connection with              
          claim 136, the obviousness rejection of claim 173 is reversed.              
                                         12                                           





Page:  Previous  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007