Ex parte MCMAHAN et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 95-4154                                                          
          Application 08/122,193                                                      

          reasonably means only the selection of one particular impedance             
          value among a plurality of selectable values as the output                  
          impedance, not a plurality of impedance values any one of which             
          may ultimately turn out to be the actual output impedance                   
          depending on something over which the user does not control.                
               While features not claimed should not be read into the                 
          claims from the specification, claim terms also must be                     
          interpreted reasonably in light of the specification.  The                  
          appellants’ disclosed invention and specification concern the               
          causing of the circuit to exhibit a specific impedance known to             
          the user.  In our view, it would not be consistent with the                 
          specification to interpret the claims as reading on something               
          which defines a range or plurality of impedance values over which           
          the actual output impedance will vary based on the characteristic           
          impedance of the transmission line or the drain current of a                
          monitoring transistor.                                                      
               Additionally, Asano does not disclose when input A is                  
          provided by a user, assuming that the input A is provided by a              
          user.  It would be mere speculation to assume that the input A is           
          provided only during a predetermined mode of operation or only              
          during reset.  Nothing precludes inputting the A signal at some             
          other time.                                                                 


                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007