Ex parte SCHWARTZ - Page 9




          Appeal No. 95-4847                                                           
          Application No. 08/079,222                                                   


          neutralized.”  In our view this also is a limitation that goes               
          to the process of manufacture of the fibrin.  Therefore, for                 
          the same reasons as were set forth above with regard to the                  
          term “fibrin” as it is utilized in claim 1, we find claim 2                  
          not to define over the combined teachings of the two                         
          references, and we will sustain the rejection of claim 2.                    
               Dependent claim 6 further limits claim 1 by adding the                  
          limitation that “the fibrin is intermixed with a polymeric                   
          material.”  While polymeric material was disclosed in both of                
          the applied references, their collective teachings did not                   
          include intermixing it with fibrin.  We therefore will not                   
          sustain the rejection of this claim.                                         
               We have carefully considered all of the appellant’s                     
          arguments.  However, as to those rejections which we have                    
          sustained, the arguments have not persuaded us that the                      
          positions taken by the examiner were in error.  We observe                   
          that there is a broad commonality of purpose in the                          
          appellant’s invention and in those of the two references.  The               
          object of the appellant’s invention is to repair vascular                    
          injury by coating a stent with fibrin to place the fibrin at                 
          the site to interact with the body (specification, page 3),                  
                                          9                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007