CAVANAGH V. MCMAHON et al. - Page 29




          Interference No. 102,668                                                    


          at the Miami meeting constituted an actual reduction to                     
          practice.  For this reason, the motion to suppress these                    
          affidavits is denied.  The question of how much of this                     
          evidence is entitled to consideration in connection with the                
          patentability issue is addressed infra in the discussion of                 
          that issue.                                                                 
                 McMahon's case for an actual reduction to practice                   
                    McMahon concedes that Jones's disclosure, at the                  
          November 1987 Miami meeting, of the structure of a device made              
          in Canada constitutes evidence of conception only, citing                   
          DeKando v. Armstrong, 169 Off. Gaz. Pat. & Trademark Office                 
          1185, 1911 Comm'r Dec. 413 (App. D.C. 1911). According to                   
          McMahon, Jones's additional detailed disclosure at that                     
          meeting of tests performed in Canada constitutes an actual                  
          reduction to practice in this country.  No authority is cited               
          in support of this proposition and we are aware of none.                    
          Testing performed abroad to prove that an invention works for               
          its intended purpose clearly constitute a foreign activity                  
          relied on to establish a date of invention and thus is                      
          excluded by 35 U.S.C. § 104 from the evidence that can be                   
          relied on to establish a date of invention in this country.                 

                                          - 29 -                                      





Page:  Previous  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007