WANG V. TUCHOLSKI - Page 114




          Interference No. 103,036                                                    


                    nonconductivity to permit the heat and                            
                    current flow to make the device operable,                         
                    since the absence of either would make the                        
                    device inoperable.  Further, in my opinion,                       
                    the natural result flowing from this                              
                    embodiment of the strength or voltage                             
                    indicator disclosed in the Burroughs '544                         
                    patent, which one of ordinary skill in the                        
                    battery art would recognize, is that the                          
                    conductive layer has sufficient thermal                           
                    insulating means under its surface to                             
                    overcome heat sinking when the device is in                       
                    contact with an electrically conductive                           
                    portion of the battery housing.                                   
                              22.  Consistent with the above,                         
                    nowhere in the Burroughs '544 patent is the                       
                    term "nonconductive layer" specifically                           
                    limited to electrically nonconductive                             
                    materials, nor is it disclosed as being                           
                    thermally conductive.  It is my opinion that                      
                    a person of ordinary skill in the art                             
                    pertaining to battery design and                                  
                    construction, when reading the Burroughs '544                     
                    patent, would understand that, at least in                        
                    connection with the embodiment of the battery                     
                    strength indicator depicted in Fig. 10, the                       
                    term "nonconductive layer" refers to both                         
                    thermally and electrically nonconductive.                         
                    This would be inherently understood because                       
                    of the fact that both controlled heat flow                        
                    and controlled current flow are discussed.                        
                    For the strength indicator to operate as                          
                    described, one would require thermal                              
                    insulation in order for the heat from the                         
                    reduced section area 65 to flow to the heat                       
                    sensitive material 70, as well as electrical                      
                    insulation in order to prevent the current                        
                    flowing through conductive layer 64 and                           
                    reduced section 65 to short circuit against                       
                    the battery housing.                                              
                              23.  In some specific instances                         
                    described in the Burroughs '544 patent, the                       


                                        -37-                                          




Page:  Previous  107  108  109  110  111  112  113  114  115  116  117  118  119  120  121  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007