WANG V. TUCHOLSKI - Page 125




          Interference No. 103,036                                                    


          sense, that does not constitute an admission that nonconductive             
          does not mean thermally nonconductive.  We are not persuaded that           
          Dr. Powers admitted that the nonconductive layer of the device of           
          Figure 10 is thermally conductive.                                          
                    We have given weight to Dr. Powers’ testimony and find            
          his testimony credible, since it is consistent with the testimony           
          adduced from witnesses associated with the opposing parties.  To            
          the extent the party Cataldi et al. urges that Dr. Powers’                  
          testimony is not credible, because he could not determine whether           
          Figure 10 of the Burroughs et al. patent was a top view or a side           
          view (see our decision on item 1, supra), he accurately depicted            
          his figure P-1, at paragraph 20, as a side view.                            
                    Consequently, we hold that the Burroughs et al.                   
          specification contains a written description for the limitation,            
          "sufficient means under one of its [the conductive layer's]                 
          surfaces to permit the heat generated" by the conductive layer to           
          change the color of the temperature sensitive color indicator, of           
          reissue claims 16, 18 to 20, 22 and 23.  For the foregoing                  
          reasons, the motion is denied as to item 5.                                 
                    In item 6, the motion urges that the Burroughs et al.             
          specification does not contain a written description for the                
          limitation, "means between the conductive layer and the battery             
          housing to permit" the heat generated by the conductive layer to            
          change the color of the temperature sensitive color indicator               
                                        -48-                                          



Page:  Previous  118  119  120  121  122  123  124  125  126  127  128  129  130  131  132  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007