Ex parte HANSON et al. - Page 42




          Appeal No. 94-3255                                                          
          Application 07/673,264                                                      


               useful to produce lysine, phenylalanine, and tryptophan                
               either singly or simultaneously.  In one embodiment,                   
               auxotrophs which are also amino acid sensitive can                     
          produce                                                                     
               from about 3 to about 5 grams 1  of lysine.  In a. -1                                      
          preferred                                                                   
               embodiment, auxotrophs which are also amino acid                       
          sensitive                                                                   
               can produce up to 8 grams/l L-lysine.  Simultaneous                    
               production of at least 4.0g 1 of L-lysine and at least. -1                                        
               1.5g 1 of L-aspartic acid can also be obtained.  In one. -1                                                               
               preferred embodiment, simultaneous production of 4.5g 1. -1              
               of L-lysine and 2.0g 1 of L-aspartic acid are obtained. -1                                               
               [(Spec., p. 14, line 15, to p. 15, line 1)].                           

               The auxotrophic bacterium of Claim 55 must exhibit                     
          “sustained growth at 50 C in nutrient media comprisingE                                                    
          methanol as a source of carbon and energy and vitamin B ”                   
                                                                 12                   
          (emphasis added) and excrete “at least about 5 g/l of lysine,               
          aspartic acid, phenylalanine, or tryptophan when grown on a                 
          media containing a nitrogen source” (emphasis added).                       
          However:                                                                    
               (1) The specification teaches that appellants’ novel                   
          amino acid producing auxotrophic bacterium requires biotin to               
          grow (Spec., p. 10, line 27).  Claim 55 appears also to be                  
          directed to amino acid producing auxotrophic bacteria which                 
          exhibit sustained growth in a nutrient media which does not                 
          contain biotin.                                                             
                                         13                                           





Page:  Previous  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007