Ex parte MAHULIKAR et al. - Page 3




           Appeal No. 95-2500                                                                 
           Application No. 07/984,147                                                         


           therein a micro-electronic device electrically interconnected                      
           to a leadframe and a composite heat spreader.  The heat                            
           spreader comprises a core layer situated between first and                         
           second cladding layers.  The composite heat spreader has a                         
           high thermal conductivity to enhance the removal of heat                           
           during the operation of the microelectronic device, in                             
           addition to having a coefficient of thermal expansion                              
           essentially equal to that of the electronic device in order to                     
           inhibit thermal fracture of the device.                                            
                Appealed claims 41, 43 and 69-74 stand rejected under                         
           35 U.S.C. § 103 as being unpatentable over the admitted prior                      
           art, Hodge and Komatsu in view of Gernitis, Hascoe or Alvarez.                     
           Claims 75 and 76 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103 as being                     
           unpatentable over the stated combination of references in                          
           further view of Kato, Butt, Yerman or Hynes.                                       
                Upon careful consideration of the opposing arguments                          
           presented on appeal, we are of the opinion that the applied                        
           prior art fails to establish a prima facie case of obviousness                     
           for the claimed subject matter.  Accordingly, we will not                          
           sustain the examiner's rejections.                                                 



                                             -3-                                              




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007