Ex parte MARX - Page 2




                 Appeal No. 1996-0208                                                                                                                   
                 Application 08/098,153                                                                                                                 


                 final rejection of claim 14, the only claim in the                                                                                     
                 application.  The subject matter on appeal is directed to a                                                                            
                 method of retrofitting a forming apparatus.                                                                                            
                          Claim 14 is reproduced below:                                                                                                 

                                   14.  A method of converting a forming apparatus for                                                                  
                 receiving a paper web and press forming multiple blanks into a                                                                         
                 plurality of three-dimensionally shaped paper products within                                                                          
                 a single die cavity in each forming cycle into a forming                                                                               
                 apparatus in which the plurality of blanks are simultaneously                                                                          
                 shaped into a plurality of three-dimensionally shaped paper                                                                            
                 products within separate die cavities in each forming cycle,                                                                           
                 comprising the steps of:                                                                                                               
                                   (a) retrofit installing an existing forming                                                                          
                 apparatus having a die set that defines a single cavity with                                                                           
                 at least one reciprocating die plate, at least one upper die                                                                           
                 plate and at least one lower die plate in vertically stacked                                                                           
                 relationship with respect to the die set of the existing                                                                               
                 forming apparatus so as to form a respective additional die                                                                            
                 cavity; and                                                                                                                            
                                   (b) forming [sic, providing] a guide means for                                                                       
                 cyclically transferring a single paperboard blank from a                                                                               
                 blanking means into each of said die cavities during a first                                                                           
                 portion of each forming cycle; wherein said guide means                                                                                
                 includes a plurality of stationary guide means, and said                                                                               
                 providing step  includes placing each of said stationary guide2                                                                                                             
                 means in alignment with a respective one of said die cavities                                                                          

                          2Antecedent basis for the claim language “said providing                                                                      
                 step” is not present.  As discussed at the oral hearing,                                                                               
                 appellant apparently intended to define step (b) of the claim                                                                          
                 as a “providing” step.  We trust that the examiner and                                                                                 
                 appellant will correct this informality prior to the allowance                                                                         
                 of this application.                                                                                                                   
                                                                           2                                                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007