Ex parte AUFDERHEIDE et al. - Page 4




          Appeal No. 96-1249                                                          
          Application 08/270,215                                                      


          dependent claim 22 and the "about 10D to about 30D" range is                
          recited in dependent claim 23.                                              
               We note that because all of the appealed claims are                    
          directed to an analog touch screen, they do not encompass the               
          matrix touch screen shown in appellants' Figure 8, which does               
          not use resistance measurements to determine the contact                    
          point, as does an analog touch screen.  Instead, it employs                 
          (a) a first plurality of transparent ITO top conductors 31                  
          running in the vertical direction, each having a respective                 
          bus bar 33 and trace 35 and (b) a second plurality of                       
          transparent ITO bottom conductors 32 running in the horizontal              
          direction, each having a respective bus bar 34 and trace 36                 
          (Spec. at 10, lines 15-21).                                                 
          When the top layer is depressed, suitable known coding                      
          circuitry examines the traces to determine which top conductor              
          is making contact with which bottom conductor (Spec. at 10,                 
          line 24 to p. 11, line 2).                                                  
          The claims                                                                  
               Claim 19, the sole independent claim, reads as follows:                
               19.  An analog touch screen, comprising:                               


                                        - 4 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007