Ex parte ORAN - Page 7




          Appeal No. 1996-1715                                                        
          Application No. 08/068,592                                                  


          system software may be changed periodically to add new                      
          functions or enhancements."  Mathur further discloses that:                 
               When the system software is changed, it becomes                        
               desirable to perform a process . . . to update the                     
               non-volatile storage devices 103 in a predetermined                    
               subset of nodes in the network so that the new                         
               system software may be used to operate the CPU's 101                   
               of the subset of nodes.                                                
          The process by which Mathur does the update involves loading                
          the software into a source node and then distributing the new               
          software to the other nodes.  Mathur discloses neither the                  
          systematic comparisons of version numbers nor timestamps and                
          systematic comparisons thereof.                                             
               Lowry relates to common databases for plural application               
          programs.  Lowry discloses tracking the various versions of                 
          data files as updates are made.  The examiner contends                      
          (Answer, page 6) that the "synchronization timestamp of the                 
          claim is identical to the checkpoint of Lowry."  The examiner               
          further explains (Supplemental Answer, page 3) that:                        
               [I]n Lowry, the snapshot file contains multiple                        
               versions of data and at checkpoint, the master data                    
               file must be synchronized to a specific version. . .                   
               . the contents of the master data file are replaced                    
               with a checkpoint version from the snapshot file . .                   
               . .  In other words, a checkpoint version is a                         
               version at a specific point in time.  Therefore,                       

                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007