Ex parte HUBERT - Page 6




          Appeal No. 96-1999                                                          
          Application 08/216,382                                                      



                    Independent claim 8 sets forth a method for impart-               
          ing velocity to a spacecraft comprising, inter alia, the steps              
          of firing a thruster, to thereby draw propellant from first                 
          and                                                                         
          second propellant tanks; and only during the firing of the                  
          thruster, controlling the flow of propellant from the tanks in              
          a manner which tends to move the actual center of mass of the               
          spacecraft relative to the thrust axis of the thruster.                     


                    Akin to the analysis in the brief (pages 3 through                
          6), our reading of the Hubert patent reveals to us that appel-              
          lant’s claimed spacecraft and method are not anticipated by                 
          this document.  Unlike the presently claimed invention, the                 
          invention of the Hubert patent (Fig. 2) addresses a spacecraft              
          with spin                                                                   


          stabilization and balance (attitude) control by transferring                
          liquid fuel between containers (propellant tanks) in a direc-               
          tion tending to reduce spin imbalance (column 3, line 30,                   
          through column 4, line 2).  It is noted that, as expressed by               

                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007