Ex parte KOGA et al. - Page 11




          Appeal No. 1996-2198                                                        
          Application 08/077,506                                                      



               Claim 2 further stands rejected under § 103 for                        
          obviousness over Kuroda in view of Baker and Webster.                       
          E.  The merits of the § 112, first paragraph, rejection                     
               Although the statement of the § 112, first paragraph                   
          rejection asserts that the claims fail to satisfy the written               
          description and best mode requirements, the examiner's                      
          arguments implicate only the enablement requirement.                        
               The examiner contention that "[t]he approximate                        
          continuous probability density function Bc is not defined in                
          the specification" (Answer at 7, lines 20-21) is unpersuasive,              
          because the examiner has not explained why the formulas given               
          at page 12 fail to adequately explain how to obtain the                     
          Gaussian probability density function.                                      
               The examiner also challenges the sufficiency of the                    
          disclosure of the second pattern forming circuit 18, which the              
          specification as filed described as follows:                                
                    The second pattern forming circuit 18 receives                    
               the state transition probability distribution A from                   
               the first pattern forming circuit 16 and the                           
               approximate continuous [feature code] probability                      
               density function Bc from the function generator 17                     
               and combines them to form a second pattern.  The                       


                                        -11-                                          





Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007