Ex parte SHAW et al. - Page 10




                 Appeal No. 1996-3525                                                                                    Page 10                        
                 Application No. 08/089,595                                                                                                             


                 clear to us that in Morris '163, a demand signal is generated                                                                          
                 upon the user moving push button 17 into operative association                                                                         
                 with the push button 37 sufficient for push button 37 to close                                                                         
                 the switch 30.  Furthermore, it is our determination that the                                                                          
                 claimed term sensor  is readable on push button 37 of Morris4                                                                                                    
                 '163 because the push button 37 is designed to respond to a                                                                            
                 physical stimulus (the motion of push button 17) and transmit                                                                          
                 a resulting impulse for operating a control (switch 30).                                                                               


                          The appellants' disclose (specification, p. 18) that the                                                                      
                 preferred sensor is an inductive sensor and that an inductive                                                                          
                 sensor is one that generates a signal in response to a                                                                                 
                 disturbance within a designated space.  However, since the                                                                             
                 claimed sensor is not limited to an inductive sensor, it would                                                                         
                 be inappropriate to apply the appellants' definition of                                                                                
                 inductive sensor to the claimed sensor since limitations are                                                                           
                 not to be read into the claims from the specification.                                                                                 


                          4Webster's Third New International Dictionary, (1971)                                                                         
                 defines sensor as "a device designed to respond to a physical                                                                          
                 stimulus (as heat or cold, light, a particular motion) and                                                                             
                 transmit a resulting impulse for interpretation or measurement                                                                         
                 or for operating a control."                                                                                                           







Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007