Ex parte HELLER et al. - Page 8




          Appeal No. 96-3697                                                           
          Serial No. 08/255,304                                                        




          rearranging address bits within the global address portion or                
          the local address portion.                                                   
                    Appellants argue that Robinson does not teach or                   
          suggest the invention recited in claim 1.  The contention is                 
          made that there is no suggestion in Robinson that dataform                   
          modules generate programs in response to an initial address                  
          bit ordering and a final address bit ordering to enable use of               
          one or more tools to perform a data reassignment among                       
          processing elements and storage locations to effect a                        
          rearrangement of address bits. Appellants urge that Robinson’s               
          system does not automatically generate a program using a                     
          selected set of tools for effecting the reassignment of data                 
          items to effect a selected rearrangement of data bits.                       
                    Lastly, appellants argue that the combination of                   
          Edelman and Robinson fails to teach or suggest the global and                
          local address portions recited in claim 1.                                   
                    In response to appellants’ arguments, the examiner                 
          asserts appellants’ rearrangement of address bits is                         
          functionally equivalent to the swapping of addresses as                      

                                           8                                           






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007