Ex parte MALHOTRA - Page 14




          Appeal No. 96-3946                                                          
          Application No. 08/208,317                                                  


          (Answer, page 8) that it would have been obvious to use the                 
          microwave drying of Ayers "because the microwave drying of                  
          Ayers, et al. drys the ink as desired by Miyamoto, et al."                  
          She further asserts (Answer, page 11) that                                  
               Ayers does not limit drying to any particular                          
               recording sheet.  And Miyamoto does not prohibit                       
               drying, in fact Miyamoto, et al. teach to dry the                      
               ink receptive layer in example 1.  Therefore,                          
               Miyamoto, et al. desire a dried recording medium.                      
               Appellants have not given sufficient reason why                        
               Miyamoto would not want a dried recording medium in                    
               the ink jet art.                                                       
               First, the drying of Example 1 of Miyamoto referenced by               
          the examiner (Answer, page 11), occurs during the preparation               
          of the medium for use in a printing process, not during the                 
          printing process itself.  Furthermore, Miyamoto discloses in                
          column 2, lines 54-62, that                                                 
               for the purpose of producing an ink jet recording                      
               sheet having a high rate of ink absorption so as to                    
               render the ink apparently dry immediately after the                    
               application, it is most effective to construct the                     
               uppermost layer, with which the ink droplets come in                   
               first contact, with pigment particles of a suitable                    
               size to utilize the capillary effect of the                            
               interparticle voids or to provide a porous layer of                    
               the similar pore size or pore radius to absorb the                     
               ink. (emphasis added)                                                  
          In other words, Miyamoto discloses that the recording medium                
          dries immediately by itself by virtue of the porosity of the                
                                         14                                           





Page:  Previous  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007