Ex parte THOMAS et al. - Page 7




          Appeal 97-1554                                                               
          Application 08/495,593                                                       

                    28. The examiner declined to give much weight to a                 
          showing in applicants' specification and a Rule 132 Schwahn                  
          declaration.                                                                 

                             Showing in the specification                              
                    29. In their specification, applicants compare fuels               
          which:                                                                       
                         (1) do not contain Component A or Component B,                
                              (2) which contain Component A and a                      
                                   polyether (not a polyetheramine), and               
                         (3) which contain a Component A and a                         
                              Component B.                                             
                    30. Component A is said to be a "polyisobutylamine"                
          having an average molecular weight of 1000 prepared as                       
          described in Kummer (specification, page 8, lines 23-26).                    
                    31. However, the specification does not reveal                     
          whether isobutene alone was used to make the                                 
          "polyisobutylamine" or whether, as Kummer would permit, a                    
          mixture of isobutene and butene was used.                                    
                    32. According to applicants, the comparisons show:                 
                         (1) unexpected results with respect to                        
                              clearness of the Component A and Component               
                                        - 7 -                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007