Ex parte KOFFRON - Page 6




          Appeal No. 98-0393                                                          
          Application No. 08/450,271                                                  


          inserting a uniform refractory body of non-regular tetrahedron              
          shape having a specific gravity less than the specific gravity              
          of the molten metal, and geometrically proportioning the                    
          refractory body by shaping it other than as a regular                       
          tetrahedron so that its center of gravity is below its center               
          of buoyant support, thereby maintaining the body in an upright              
          orientation which generally conforms with the shape of the                  
          vortex.  Like the vortex inhibitor of appellant, the specific               
          gravity of the reference inhibitor "is adjusted to buoyantly                
          support the body at the interface of the layer of slag and the              
          layer of molten metal" (compare Koffron at column 2, lines 43-              
          46 with appellant's specification at column 7, lines 9-11).                 
          Also, the body of Koffron's vortex inhibitor takes on the                   
          shape of a tapered, polygonal body having an apex that is                   
          oriented downwardly upon insertion in the molten metal (column              
          2, lines 8 et seq. and Figure 2).  Since both the claimed and               
          referenced inhibitors have a specific gravity which buoyantly               
          supports the inhibitor at the interface of the molten metal                 
          and slag layers, it follows that the center of gravity of the               
          referenced inhibitor is below its center of buoyancy.  Also,                
          while a tetrahedron is the preferred shape of the referenced                

                                         -6-                                          




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007