Ex parte BRENNER et al. - Page 16




          Appeal No. 98-1012                                                          
          Serial No. 08/117,342                                                       




                growth promoting agents (e.g., peptone, lactose) (see                 
                Table 1);                                                             
                a buffer and the claimed pH (e.g., p. 337, col. 1, lines              
                8-12); and,                                                           
                chromogenic and fluorogenic detecting compounds (p.                   
                336+, starting under Detection of Activity of Individual              
                Enzymes).                                                             




          Manafi does not teach:                                                      
                an agent to suppress growth of gram positive cocci &                  
                spore-forming organisms; or                                           
                an agent to suppress growth of non-coliform gram                      
                negative bacteria.                                                    

          Manafi therefore teaches a medium for detecting E. coli and                 
          coliforms as claimed but without the claimed suppressing                    
          agents. This can be summarized as follows:                                  


                          Bacteria   Bacteria    Bacteria   Bacteria    -             
                            Gram-     Gram-       Gram-      Gram-                    
                                     Coliform    Coliform  Non-Coliform               
                                      Other      E. Coli                              
          MANAFI discloses   -        grow        grow         -        -             



                                          16                                          





Page:  Previous  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007