Ex parte MCCALLION - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1997-1451                                                        
          Application 08/145,974                                                      


               For the reasons set forth below, we cannot sustain this                
          rejection.                                                                  
               As correctly explained by the appellant, the structural                
          member disclosed by Van Beersel relates to thermally insulated              
          pipe joints and is totally unlike the here claimed corrosion-               
          resistant structural member which involves protecting from                  
          corrosion-causing elements the joint that connects reinforcing              
          rods.  For example, the Van Beersel member does not include a               
          sleeve having inner and outer layers whereby, when heat is                  
          applied to the structural member, the liquefied inner layer is              
          forced "into intimate contact with the corrodible surfaces" of              
          the reinforcing rod connecting ends (appealed claim 1).                     
          Similarly, Van Beersel contains no teaching or suggestion of                
          the structural member defined by appealed claim 1 which                     
          results in "the liquefied thermoplastic polymer coating the                 
          corrodible surfaces and the joint, and exuding from open ends               
          of the sleeve, forming a bead and acting as a barrier to                    
          corrosion-causing elements".                                                
               Moreover, as convincingly argued by the appellant, the                 
          Weatherby reference fails to remedy the above discussed                     
          deficiencies of Van Beersel.  For example, while Weatherby                  
                                         -5-                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007