Ex parte LOCKWOOD - Page 10




          Appeal No. 1997-2678                                                        
          Application No. 08/347,270                                                  


          inquiries to a user and to respond to answers to those                      
          inquiries by the user.  Therefore, one can broadly interpret                
          Lockwood as disclosing the claimed “inquiring sequences of                  
          data.”  Since Lockwood presents options to a user and responds              
          to various selections, Lockwood also may be said to have a                  
          “means for outputting said informing and inquiring sequences                
          on said video screen,” as claimed.  Lockwood also appears to                
          disclose many of the other claimed features.                                
               However, independent claim 1 also requires a “means for                
          controlling” the storing means, the outputting means and the                
          transmitting means.  Lockwood clearly has a “means for                      
          controlling.” But claim 1 requires that the means for                       
          controlling includes “means for fetching additional inquiring               
          sequences in response to a plurality of said data entered                   
          through said means for entering and in response to information              
          received from said central processor.”  While Lockwood may                  
          fetch additional inquiring sequences (as in presenting                      
          additional questions or options to a user) in response to a                 
          user input, we find no suggestion in Lockwood of fetching the               
          additional inquiring sequences in response to both the user                 
          entry of data and to information received from the central                  
                                         10                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007