Ex parte TOMARU et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1997-3024                                                        
          Application 08/325,476                                                      

          claim 1 indicate that the claim is directed to “[c]oating                   
          equipment with an extrusion coating head disposed between run               
          guide means spaced a distance apart and facing a continuously               
          running support retained by said run guide means” (emphasis                 
          added).  Thus, in addition to stating that the claimed                      
          “equipment” includes an extrusion coating head and run guide                
          means, lines 1-3 also state that the coating head “faces” the               
          continuously running support and that the continuously running              
          support is “retained by” the run guide means.  From our                     
          perspective, the recitation of the relationship between the                 
          coating head and the continuously running support (i.e., the                
          coating head “facing” the support) and the recitation of the                
          relationship between the continuously running support and the               
          run guide means (i.e., the support being “retained by” the run              
          guide means) amounts to a positive recitation of the                        
          continuously running support in conjunction with the coating                
          equipment elements set forth elsewhere in claim 1.  This being              
          the case, we believe an artisan could indeed calculate the                  
          distance between the support and the regulation plates, as                  
          called for within the body of claim 1, since both the support               
          and the regulation plates are positively recited in the claim.              

                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007