Ex parte SPORZYNSKI et al. - Page 16




          Appeal No. 1997-3709                                                        
          Application 08/582,034                                                      


          second axially extending dimension” as including any axially                
          extending measurement of the passageway end taken near the                  
          edge of the passageway end opening.                                         
               Reading independent claim 3 on the Figure 4 brake rotor                
          of Soltis, we find that the Figure 4 brake rotor comprises an               
          annular mounting flange and an annular friction disk having a               
          generally elliptical air passageway extending radially                      
          therethrough.  The outer end of the passageway has a first                  
          center axially extending dimension (A1) and a first                         
          circumferentially extending dimension (A3), and the inner end               
          of the passageway has a second center axially extending                     
          dimension (B1) and a second circumferentially extending                     
          dimension (B3) such that (B1) > (A1) and (B3) < (A3), as                    
          required by claim 3.  Moreover, based on our above                          
          interpretation of the claim terminology “a first axially                    
          extending dimension” and “a second axially extending                        
          dimension,” we find that the Figure 4 passageway of Soltis has              
          a first axially extending dimension (A2) as measured near the               
          edge of the outer end of the passageway and a second axially                
          extending dimension (B2) as measured near the edge of the                   
          inner end of the passageway, such that (A2) < (A1) and (B2) <               
                                        -16-                                          





Page:  Previous  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007