Ex parte GO - Page 9




          Appeal No. 1998-1895                                       Page 9           
          Application No. 08/425,990                                                  


                    FIG. 10 illustrates a configuration of two                        
               pyramid ICs, 1002 and 1004, and two frame stores                       
               1006 and 1008 as a reduce-expand pyramid module.                       
               This module may be used for encoding and decoding                      
               images for data reduction, image enhancement, noise                    
               reduction image merging and other image processing                     
               functions where it is desirable to reconstruct an                      
               image from a pyramid after some processing is                          
               performed on pyramid images.                                           
          Col. 20, l. 63 - col. 21, l. 2.  In summary, the paragraph                  
          teaches that van der Wal's reduce-expand pyramid module is                  
          useful "where it is desirable to reconstruct an image from a                
          pyramid after some processing is performed on pyramid images."              
          There is no evidence, however, that Schreiber employs, let                  
          alone processes, such pyramid images such that it would be                  
          desirable to reconstruct an image from a pyramid.                           


               Relying on AAPA as evidence that "wavelets provide for                 
          efficiency and high compression ratios" (Examiner's Answer at               
          6), on Carnahan to "demonstrate[] the commonality of using a                
          wavelet transform in image coding" (id.), on Ohsawa to                      
          "provide[] for a series of low-pass filters in an encoding                  
          apparatus" and "for different cut-off frequencies" (id. at 8),              
          and on Toriu "only ... as an example to show the commonality                
          of a typical horizontal and vertical gradient operations" (id.              







Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007