Ex parte SHOHARA - Page 8




          Appeal No. 1998-2608                                                        
          Application 08/570,439                                                      


          put, the antennas of the fixed base station, as well as its                 
          corresponding fixed subscriber station, must be directed to                 
          each other and therefore are considered assigned.                           
               In contrast to appellant's view that there is no teaching              
          and suggestion in Wang of a database of measured co-channel                 
          interference characteristics, we respectively disagree.  The                
          examiner properly relies on the preferred channel list (PCL)                
          of Wang as a basis from which to allocate communication                     
          channels, which are specifically ranked in accordance with the              
          occurrence of prior events on the channels, or a channel                    
          history, which is in-part based upon the mean quality margin                
          and current channel quality determinations.  The discussion at              
          column 1, lines 36-45 of Wang relied upon by the examiner                   
          indicates that the co-channel interference of the type                      
          discussed in Hamabe is also used as a measure of quality as                 
          discussed in this reference.  Dynamic channel allocation                    
          methods are also taught in Wang to complement those in Hamabe               
          to minimize or eliminate this co-channel interference.                      
               In addition to the preferred channel list comprising a                 
          database of Wang comparable to the claimed database of claim 1              
          for example, Hamabe utilizes a list of candidate channels                   
                                          8                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007