Ex parte SHOHARA - Page 9




          Appeal No. 1998-2608                                                        
          Application 08/570,439                                                      


          which also comprises such a comparable database of the type                 
          claimed.  The basis for the discussion of such a list in                    
          Hamabe is derived from the examiner-noted discussion of the                 
          middle paragraph of column 1 of this reference, which also                  
          teaches that a list of available channels according to past                 
          history of co-channel interference is kept in the prior art to              
          Hamabe which is utilized as a basis for determining future                  
          dynamic channel allocations as taught in this reference.  It                
          is also taught in the context of uplink and downlink signals.               
          As a measure of co-channel interference determinations to                   
          determine channel quality, the noise value associated with the              
          respective channels is also determined as discussed in the                  
          latter portion of column 6 of Hamabe.  These values must                    
          obviously be measured to the extent claimed as are the                      
          measurement of all values determined as expressed at the                    
          bottom of column 4 of Wang.  The discussion at column 9                     
          associated with Figure 8 of Wang also indicates that a signal-              
          to noise-ratio and interference ratios are discussed as a                   
          measure of quality determinations in Wang.  We are therefore                
          unpersuaded by the appellant's argument at page 9 of the brief              
          that Wang is not concerned with interference factors.                       
                                          9                                           





Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007