Ex parte GARBER et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 1998-2815                                                        
          Application No. 08/648,790                                                  

          determination must be made.  The first program is a complex                 
          expert system that includes databases and libraries for use by              
          an expert to create a simpler program to be used by a non-                  
          expert, the simpler program asks specific questions of the                  
          non-expert and displays a decision or suggested questions to                
          ask an expert.  Hayward provides an example of use in a                     
          medical field to help a patient determine a course of action                
          and/or suggested questions to ask the doctor, see Figures 14-               
          28.  We find nothing in Hayward that makes reference to a                   
          respirator or a method of selecting a respirator on the basis               
          of a first and second chemical.                                             


               With respect to Grilk, we understand Grilk to teach a                  
          Carbon Monoxide (CO) monitor that includes a sensor for                     
          determining the concentration of carbon monoxide present, an                
          LED for displaying the concentration and a microprocessor for               
          calculating the health hazard to a person occasioned by the                 
          level of carbon monoxhemoglobin in the blood of that person                 
          resulting from breathing the known/determined concentrations                
          of CO over a period of time.  Like Hayward, Grilk makes no                  
          reference to a respirator or a method of selecting a                        

                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007