Ex parte PEPPEL - Page 16




          Appeal No. 1998-2848                                                        
          Application 08/398,862                                                      

          any case, it is not known what is meant by either phrase and                
          we find no description of either phrase in the specification.               
               We reverse the § 101 rejection of claims 21-37.  Where                 
          the claimed subject matter is indefinite, an evaluation                     
          thereof relative to statutory subject matter is inappropriate.              
          Cf. In re Wilson, 424 F.2d 1382, 1385, 165 USPQ 494, 496 (CCPA              
          1970) ("If no reasonably definite meaning can be ascribed to                
          certain terms in the claim, the subject matter does not become              
          obvious--the claim becomes indefinite); In re Steele,                       
          305 F.2d 859, 862, 134 USPQ 292, 295 (CCPA 1962) ("[O]ur                    
          analysis of the claims leaves us in a quandry as to what is                 
          covered by them.  We think the examiner and the board were                  
          wrong in relying on what at best are speculative assumptions                
          as to the meaning of the claims and basing a rejection under                
          35 U.S.C. § 103 thereon.").                                                 

               Independent claim 38 and dependent claim 39                            
               System claim 38 recites "said ETC including a display                  
          system, a housing, software, a battery, a CPU, and an LCD                   
          display."  Thus, system claim 38 recites physical structure                 
          which has not been addressed by the Examiner.  Although                     
          claim 38 does not recite that the ETC data structure is                     
                                       - 16 -                                         





Page:  Previous  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007