CRAGG et al. V. MARTIN V. FOGARTY et al. - Page 56




          Interference No. 104,192                                                    
          Cragg v. Martin v. Fogarty                                                  

          section.  According to Cragg, Fogarty’s second leg is also not              
          joined to the anchor section, evidently for the same reason,                
          and thus there can be no description for a “means for joining               
          a second leg to said anchor section.”  Cragg’s arguments                    
          assume that there must be direct contact between the first leg              
          and the anchor section and between the second leg and the                   
          anchor section.  We see no reason, however, to construe claim               
          62 of Fogarty’s uninvolved application 08/684,508 so narrowly               
          as to require direct or immediate contact between the first                 
          and second legs and the anchor section.                                     
               Cragg does not contend that Fogarty’s application                      
          08/684,508 sets forth a special definition for the word “join”              
          that is different from the ordinary meaning of the term.  We                
          understand the word “join” as sufficiently broad to encompass               
          an indirect connection through an intermediate member.  See,                
          for example, Merriam-Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary, Tenth                 
          Edition, Copyright © 1999, which defines “join” as follows:                 
               1 a: to put or bring together so as to form a unit .                   
               . . . . b: to connect (as points) by a line c:                         
               ADJOIN 2: to put or bring into close association or                    
               relationship . . . 3: to engage in (battle) 4 a: to                    
               come into the company of . . . b: to associate                         
               oneself with . . .                                                     
          If the first and second legs in Fogarty’s application                       
                                       - 56 -                                         





Page:  Previous  49  50  51  52  53  54  55  56  57  58  59  60  61  62  63  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007