CRAGG et al. V. MARTIN V. FOGARTY et al. - Page 62




          Interference No. 104,192                                                    
          Cragg v. Martin v. Fogarty                                                  

          in this interference or a new interference with Fogarty does                
          not mean Fogarty has been subjected to prejudice.  A                        
          dominating claim is not necessarily a claim drawn to the same               
          patentable invention as a dominated claim.  In either case,                 
          however, with regard to Cragg’s allegedly dominating claim 89               
          Fogarty has shown no prejudice by the denial of its                         
          preliminary motion 8.                                                       


               5.   Fogarty’s preliminary motion 10                                   
               Fogarty’s preliminary motion 10 sought to be accorded                  
          benefit of the earlier filing date of application 08/255,681,               
          with respect to the count proposed in connection with                       
          Fogarty’s preliminary motion 8.  Consequently, preliminary                  
          motion 10 is contingent upon the granting of preliminary                    
          motion 8.  Because Fogarty’s preliminary motion 8 was properly              
          denied, Fogarty’s preliminary motion 10 was correctly                       
          dismissed as moot.                                                          
               6.   Cragg’s Motion to Suppress                                        
               Cragg has filed a motion to suppress five exhibits FE-                 
          3001, FE-3002, FE-3004, FE-3005, and CE-1019.  These are                    
          exhibits identified by party Fogarty, prior to submission of                
          its brief at final hearing, as those which Fogarty intended to              
                                       - 62 -                                         





Page:  Previous  55  56  57  58  59  60  61  62  63  64  65  66  67  68  69  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007