Ex parte OSTENDORFF et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 2000-0212                                                        
          Application 08/914,477                                                      


               a pair of reversible motor drive units for applying a                  
          torque to each of said wheels and an opposite-direction                     
          reaction torque to said body, said reaction torque acting to                
          flip said body pivoting said trailing end over said wheels                  
          when said motor drive units reverse the torque applied to said              
          wheels.                                                                     
          Appellants assert that claim 16 additionally distinguishes                  
          over the prior art in that it requires a toy vehicle having an              
          elongated body with a pair of rotating wheels and a pair of                 
          reversible motors for applying torque to the wheels and an                  
          opposite reaction torque to the body.                                       
               We agree with appellants to the extent that we find no                 
          disclosure or suggestion in the combination of Travers and Oda              
          that the motors would produce sufficient torque to act to flip              
          the body of the Travers toy car, pivoting the trailing end                  
          over the wheels, as recited in claim 16.  Rejection (1) of                  
          claim 16 accordingly will not be sustained.                                 
          Rejection (2)                                                               
               The claims to which this rejection applies having been                 
          grouped together by appellants (brief, page 5), we select                   
          claim 10 from the group and will decide rejection (2) based                 
          thereon.  37 CFR 1.192(c)(7).                                               
               Claim 10 recites:                                                      

                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007