Ex parte LENTZ - Page 8




          Appeal No. 2000-0917                                       Page 8           
          Application No. 09/104,763                                                  


               Villanueva's invention relates generally to mounting                   
          brackets or carriers for releasably mounting portable audio                 
          equipment to other apparatus such as vehicles having a                      
          forward wheel controlled by a combination stem and handlebars,              
          examples being bicycles, tricycles, mopeds and motorcycles.                 
          Villanueva teaches (column 1, lines 18-54) that                             
                    Operators of bicycles have heretofore had to do                   
               without audio entertainment unless they somehow carried                
               audio equipment on their persons and used headphones to                
               carry the sounds to their ears.  . . .                                 
                    In most states, the operator of a motorcycle cannot               
               legally wear earphones because of the fact that earphones              
               excessively attenuate ambient sounds, such as voices,                  
               horns and sirens. Safe driving laws require that the                   
               operator of a motor vehicle be aware of ambient sounds.                
               Unfortunately, most states do not have the same                        
               restriction concerning bicycle riders. With the                        
               proliferation of personal portable, pocket size                        
               stereophonic audio equipment with earphones, the                       
               potential for dangerous situations is immediately                      
               apparent. There are many people, most notably children                 
               and teenagers, riding bicycles while wearing earphones.                
                    In the absence of earphones, stereophonic equipment               
               would need to be carried in front and centered, with                   
               respect to the operator, without inconveniencing the                   
               operator and without impairing the safe operation of the               
               bicycle. One type of such apparatus exists where a                     
               combination radio with its speakers is removably mounted               
               to the handlebars of a motorcycle. However, it is a                    
               rather sophisticated arrangement, much like an automobile              
               radio installation, except that the housing for the radio              
               and its associated speakers is mounted on rods some                    
               distance above the handlebars. It uses the motorcycle                  







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007